What are we really looking for when we build a brand?

Cathal Smyth, Executive Director, Strategy, reflects on what the Building Brands Wrong series has revealed about the nature of brands – and why brand strategy is better understood as an interpretation of an organization than the discovery of an enduring truth.
When we started the Building Brands Wrong series, I thought we’d explore a fairly practical problem: the distance between the orderly way brands are developed and the less orderly way organizations actually work.
We’ve looked at what happens when carefully developed brand strategies encounter websites, communications teams, employees and the everyday decisions that shape how organizations are understood and experienced.
Along the way, through writing these articles and talking with clients and colleagues, I’ve found myself returning to a question that sits beneath many of the issues we’ve been exploring.
What exactly are we trying to define when we develop a brand?
It sounds like a question we should have answered a long time ago – defining brands is what people like me have spent our working lives doing.
But the more I’ve thought about it, the more I’ve wondered whether some of the problems we’ve been describing have their roots in how we understand brands in the first place.
The search for something essential
Brand development tends to begin with a search for something fundamental about an organization – essence, DNA, true character, purpose – qualities that make it what it is and explain why it’s not like everything else.
We want to understand what really matters about an organization, what makes it distinctive, and what should guide its future. Without that understanding, brand strategy risks becoming just a collection of appealing statements.
But there’s an assumption embedded in the language we use. We talk as though an organization’s true identity already exists, waiting for someone with the right expertise and insight to uncover it.
The brand strategist becomes an investigator, searching beneath the complexity for the essential truth that explains everything else.
There is something important in the ambition to understand an organization more deeply. But I’m less certain about simply uncovering something that was there all along.
Are we discovering an organization’s defining truth? Or are we developing an interpretation of it, making choices about which characteristics matter, how they fit together, and what they might mean for the future?
The organization and our description of it
Organizations aren’t blank sheets of paper. They have histories, capabilities, relationships, and established ways of working. These are real characteristics that shape what an organization can do, how it behaves, and how other people experience it.
Some are remarkably durable. An established culture doesn’t disappear because a leadership team wants it to. A reputation built over decades can survive several changes of strategy. Organizations are also complex. They can differ across divisions or geographies, and they can have competing priorities and contradictory characteristics. Some things change quickly, others barely change for years.
We take that complexity and attempt to capture it in a relatively small number of statements and outputs. And so, we should. An effective brand strategy has to make choices. It needs to identify what’s important, establish priorities, and give people something clear enough to work with.
The difficulty comes when we treat the resulting description as though it is the organization, rather than an interpretation of it. An organization exists beyond our attempts to describe it. Its people continue to make decisions, its relationships develop, and its internal contradictions remain, whether or not they fit our brand framework.
The brand itself is something else again. It’s formed through the meanings, associations, and expectations that develop around an organization, through what it does, what it says, and how people encounter it. These can become remarkably established, but they won’t necessarily be the same for every audience.
Brand strategy is our deliberate attempt to understand and influence all of this. And while these are related things, they aren’t interchangeable.
A positioning might identify a genuine strength without capturing everything that makes the company what it is. Values may express important commitments while overlooking parts of the culture. Brand strategy involves judgment and selection, not simply uncovering truths.
Some interpretations are more faithful to the reality of the organization, or more useful in guiding decisions, than others. Some are appealing on paper but difficult to reconcile with how the business actually works.
Looking back at the subjects we’ve explored in this series, I feel that we’ve repeatedly encountered different versions of that same difficulty. The framework makes sense until it meets a decision it hadn’t anticipated. The brand promises one thing while the experience of working with the organization suggests another. Different teams develop their own interpretations because the approved definition doesn’t fully address the realities they encounter.
These aren’t simply failures of implementation. Maybe they also tell us something about the limitations of the original description.
When the description changes the reality
There’s another complication in the mix too. Brand strategy doesn’t just describe an organization. It can influence what that organization becomes.
A company may define itself around a particular capability or ambition. Leadership can use that positioning to guide investment, recruitment, product development and communications. Over time, these decisions may bring the organization closer to the description it has adopted. That’s part of what makes brand strategy valuable: it can express not only what a business is, but what it wants to become.
That creates a two-way relationship. The reality of the organization should inform the brand strategy, which can in turn influence how the organization develops. It’s a continuing dialogue between what exists, what we understand about it and what we are trying to make possible.
Much of this happens without anyone formally revisiting the strategy. Organizations develop new capabilities, acquire businesses, enter markets, and learn things that weren’t apparent when the strategy was agreed. Some developments reinforce the existing positioning. Others challenge it. The question is whether we allow that experience to inform our understanding of the brand or continue to treat the original strategy as the definitive answer.
This doesn’t mean brands need to change constantly. Some characteristics and commitments endure for many years. But preserving what matters isn’t necessarily the same as preserving the words we once chose to describe it.
How long does an eternal truth last?
All of which brings me to something I’ve always found slightly curious about our industry. Brand agencies spend a lot on discovering the enduring essence of organizations. And we also spend a lot of time rebranding them – even when the underlying business hasn’t changed all that much.
I’ve been involved in enough of these exercises to know that the work can be serious, valuable, and revealing. I’m not questioning the need for it. What I’m less sure about is the confidence with which we sometimes present the results.
The usual answer, of course, is that the previous agency didn’t quite get it right. We believe we can do better. I’ve certainly made that argument and believed it to be true. A new interpretation can be more accurate, revealing, or useful than the previous one.
But a better interpretation is still an interpretation. It doesn’t suddenly become the definitive truth.
Maybe we should be more candid about what brand strategy actually involves: developing a useful understanding of an organization, grounded in its reality and ambitions, that can help it make choices about its future.
That doesn’t make the work less important. It makes it more demanding. And it suggests that brand strategy is something an organization should work with and learn from, rather than simply adopt and preserve.
There are practical implications for how we develop brands and help organizations use them. I’ll return to those as we bring this series to a close.
But there’s also one slightly uncomfortable question for those of us who work in agencies. For an industry that makes a living helping organizations discover eternal truths, perhaps it’s commercially quite convenient to keep finding new ones.
If you’re thinking about how your brand can better reflect the reality and ambitions of your organization, get in touch.
Find out more about our Building Brands Wrong series
Share article
